The Nocturnists

Season

1

Episode

0

|

Trust in Medicine with Medscape, featuring Neha Pathak, MD and Dr. Perry Wilson, MD

What does it take to earn someone's trust, and what happens when medicine loses it?

In this special episode, produced in partnership with Medscape Medical News and their Healing a Broken Trust editorial initiative, Emily speaks with physicians and medical communicators Dr. Neha Pathak and Dr. Perry Wilson about the growing divide between patients and the healthcare system. They explore the forces driving medical mistrust, from rising healthcare costs and rushed appointments to social media, AI, the wellness industry, and the challenge of communicating evolving scientific evidence. Along the way, they consider what traditional medicine can learn from alternative approaches, why listening to patients matters as much as providing accurate information, and how healthcare might begin to rebuild trust. The conversation offers an early look at the questions at the heart of The Nocturnists' Trust in Medicine, a new documentary podcast series coming in Spring 2027.

Want to hear more about trust in medicine? We're working on a new documentary podcast series, Trust in Medicine, coming in Spring 2027. 

0:00/1:34

The Nocturnists

Season

1

Episode

0

|

Trust in Medicine with Medscape, featuring Neha Pathak, MD and Dr. Perry Wilson, MD

What does it take to earn someone's trust, and what happens when medicine loses it?

In this special episode, produced in partnership with Medscape Medical News and their Healing a Broken Trust editorial initiative, Emily speaks with physicians and medical communicators Dr. Neha Pathak and Dr. Perry Wilson about the growing divide between patients and the healthcare system. They explore the forces driving medical mistrust, from rising healthcare costs and rushed appointments to social media, AI, the wellness industry, and the challenge of communicating evolving scientific evidence. Along the way, they consider what traditional medicine can learn from alternative approaches, why listening to patients matters as much as providing accurate information, and how healthcare might begin to rebuild trust. The conversation offers an early look at the questions at the heart of The Nocturnists' Trust in Medicine, a new documentary podcast series coming in Spring 2027.

Want to hear more about trust in medicine? We're working on a new documentary podcast series, Trust in Medicine, coming in Spring 2027. 

0:00/1:34

About Our Guest

Dr. Neha Pathak, MD, FACP, DipABLM, is Chief Physician Editor for Health and Lifestyle Medicine at WebMD, overseeing the network of physicians who ensure accuracy across the site. She's dual board-certified in internal medicine and lifestyle medicine, with a focus on nutrition, sleep, and behavior-change strategies for health. Pathak hosts WebMD's Health Discovered podcast and reports on the intersection of lifestyle, environment, and health. She holds degrees from Harvard University and Weill Cornell Medical College.

F. Perry Wilson, MD, MSCE, is a nephrologist and physician-scientist at Yale School of Medicine, where he is an associate professor of medicine and public health and the founding director of the Clinical and Translational Research Accelerator. His research focuses on pragmatic clinical trials of digital health tools embedded in the electronic health record. An accomplished science communicator, he co-hosts the evidence-based health podcast Wellness, Actually which examines the hard data behind wellness fads. He is the author of How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't, a book about why trust in medicine has eroded and how patients can better evaluate the science behind their care.


About The Show

The Nocturnists is an award-winning medical storytelling podcast, hosted by physician Emily Silverman. We feature personal stories from frontline clinicians, conversations with healthcare-related authors, and art-makers. Our mission is to humanize healthcare and foster joy, wonder, and curiosity among clinicians and patients alike.

resources

Credits

About Our Guest

Dr. Neha Pathak, MD, FACP, DipABLM, is Chief Physician Editor for Health and Lifestyle Medicine at WebMD, overseeing the network of physicians who ensure accuracy across the site. She's dual board-certified in internal medicine and lifestyle medicine, with a focus on nutrition, sleep, and behavior-change strategies for health. Pathak hosts WebMD's Health Discovered podcast and reports on the intersection of lifestyle, environment, and health. She holds degrees from Harvard University and Weill Cornell Medical College.

F. Perry Wilson, MD, MSCE, is a nephrologist and physician-scientist at Yale School of Medicine, where he is an associate professor of medicine and public health and the founding director of the Clinical and Translational Research Accelerator. His research focuses on pragmatic clinical trials of digital health tools embedded in the electronic health record. An accomplished science communicator, he co-hosts the evidence-based health podcast Wellness, Actually which examines the hard data behind wellness fads. He is the author of How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't, a book about why trust in medicine has eroded and how patients can better evaluate the science behind their care.


About The Show

The Nocturnists is an award-winning medical storytelling podcast, hosted by physician Emily Silverman. We feature personal stories from frontline clinicians, conversations with healthcare-related authors, and art-makers. Our mission is to humanize healthcare and foster joy, wonder, and curiosity among clinicians and patients alike.

resources

Credits

This episode is sponsored and produced in partnership with Medscape.

Transcript

Note: The Nocturnists is an audio-first experience with emotion and sound design that can be difficult to fully capture in text. Transcripts are provided to support accessibility and reference, but may contain minor inaccuracies. If quoting in print, please consult the audio when possible.

Emily Silverman: You're listening to The Nocturnists. I'm Emily Silverman. What makes us trust our doctors? Is it their knowledge, their experience, the way they listen, or simply the feeling that they have our best interests at heart? What happens when that trust begins to break down? Today, we're partnering with Medscape Medical News as part of their editorial initiative, Healing a Broken Trust, which examines the erosion of public trust in medicine and science, and what it might take to rebuild it. This is a subject we've been thinking about a lot at The Nocturnists as we work on our new podcast documentary series, Trust in Medicine, slated for release in the spring of 2027.

For today's conversation, I'm joined by two physicians who spend a lot of time thinking about how medical information reaches the public. Dr. Neha Pathik is an internist, lifestyle medicine physician, and chief physician editor for Health and Lifestyle Medicine at WebMD. Dr. Perry Wilson is a nephrologist, researcher, author, and science communicator at Yale.

Together, we explore why patients are increasingly turning to social media, AI, and the wellness industry for answers. What traditional medicine can learn from these alternatives, and why even the best scientific evidence can fall short when patients don't feel heard. We also talk about medical reversals, the challenge of communicating uncertainty, and the importance of making space for patients' questions, fears, and experiences. Take a listen to my conversation with Neha and Perry.

[music]

Emily: I am Dr. Emily Silverman. I'm an internal medicine physician and the creator and host of The Nocturnists Medical Storytelling Podcast, and I am sitting here today with Dr. Neha Pathak and Dr. Perry Wilson to talk about trust in medicine. Neha and Perry, thank you so much for coming on.

Neha Pathik: Thanks so much.

Perry Wilson: Thanks for having us.

Emily: Before we dive in, I just wanted to share a little bit with the audience about each of you and who you are. Neha, you are WebMD's chief physician editor for health and lifestyle medicine, trained in internal medicine and lifestyle medicine, on faculty at the Atlanta VA Medical Center's Quality Scholars Program, an adjunct assistant professor of medicine at Emory, and a lecturer at the Yale School of Public Health.

You also host WebMD's podcast Health Discovered. Perry, you are a nationally recognized physician, researcher, educator, and writer who has a weekly video series on Medscape's Impact Factor from 2018 through August 2026, which breaks down new research for clinicians. You're also an associate professor at the Yale School of Medicine and director of clinical and translational research. You're also the author of How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't: Learning Who to Trust to Get and Stay Healthy.

Obviously, that's very relevant to our conversation today. To dive in, I'd love to hear each of you speak a little bit about your clinical life, and then a little bit about your life as a public communicator because both of you do both. You see patients, and you also speak to the public. Tell us a little bit about what that looks like for each of you.

Neha: I can start. I am essentially a primary care doctor who focuses on lifestyle medicine. My clinical work has been mostly within the VA healthcare system, where I also do a lot of quality improvement within the VA, so quality improvement work. Outside of the VA, I volunteer at a free clinic for undocumented patients, refugees, and those who do not have health insurance. I started working in health communication when my patients would come into the office and say that they were very scared about something because they read something on WebMD, and it told them that they had X, Y,, and Z condition.

Initially, that would be very distressing for me as a primary care doctor, where I was like, "Well, why aren't you listening to me? Why are you listening to WebMD?" I would have them bring in this information. When I read it, it seemed actually completely properly sourced. It seemed very accurate. It seemed like it was very balanced, and that it didn't really lead someone to think that they had X, Y, and Z most extreme condition. That's when I started to realize people are concerned about something.

They're not telling me what that is, and they're confirming their worst fear online or through social media. It's my job to understand what that is and communicate it in a way when I'm one-on-one with a patient or when I'm talking sort of more at a population level through writings in the media or on social media, in a way that is nuanced, accurate, but also allowing people to say, "I get that, but this is the thing that I'm the most scared about. Help me understand why it's not this." I think that's really what led me to come to WebMD to work here and to try to do that in the clinic, but also on a more sort of broader scale level.

Emily: Great. Perry?

Perry: Well, I'm a nephrologist by training. I'm a kidney doctor. That means I see people with chronic kidney disease, acute kidney injury in the hospital, spend a fair amount of time in the intensive care unit. The joke is no one's ever happy to see the kidney doctor walk into their room at the hospital. That's my clinical experience. That's probably 25% of my time. 75% is clinical research. I run a research program here at Yale that does a lot of clinical trials, research with electronic health record data.

My training was really in that world of statistics and trial design and biases and confounding and all of those things that we learn and teach in medical school, critical appraisal of the literature. I find that stuff really interesting. I know a lot of people think it's boring, but I think those types of errors that doctors make in interpreting the literature was how I initially got interested in public communication, started working with Medscape on Impact Factor, which is really directed towards healthcare providers in that language and at that level.

More recently, I wanted to expand out a little bit more to the general population, which led to this book for the lay public called How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't, which really tries to explore where we go wrong as doctors and how we fail our patients, often not through lack of knowledge or errors or poor diagnosis, but through failure to establish trust. Most recently, trying to do some real data-driven exploration of wellness trends, which are taking over our outpatient population based on Instagram and TikTok and stuff like that.

I have a new podcast with Emily Ostrer called Wellness Actually, which explores a topic ranging from creatine supplementation to red light therapy to declining sperm counts and all this kind of stuff, and actually digs into is there any data to support what the people online are telling you? It's what keeps me sane in between dealing with prior authorizations and other hassles of being a doctor in the modern era.

Emily: There's so much I want to ask you both about what you just said, but before I do, I wanted to just start with something really basic, which is just to talk about trust as a concept. I was telling some of the other folks we were talking to earlier today that here at The Nocturnists, we're working on an audio podcast documentary series on trust in medicine. As part of our research, we went out into the street with a microphone and just asked random people, people on a college campus, people at the mall, people at Walmart, "What is trust? What is trust to you? What does trust mean?" I was wondering how each of you think about that word, trust. What is it and what does it mean?

Neha: Go ahead, Perry. I'll let you go. We can ping-pong back and forth.

Perry: Yes. I think we all kind of have a sense of it, but it's hard to put it in words. For me, it's the willingness to do something you wouldn't otherwise do because of your belief or faith in another person. Fundamentally, when it comes to our interactions with patients, where things don't get gummed up, is when we're all in agreement, and everyone wants to quit smoking, and you want them to quit smoking.

Then it's less of a trust issue, and it's more of a knowledge issue. What are the best pathways, and how do we do this? Trust really comes up when there's a discrepancy there, when you're saying, "I'm asking you to make a change that you might not have made otherwise, and you may not even believe that it works." That's the hardest part of medicine where we often fall short. What do you think, Neha?

Neha: I reflect on trust with sort of my lived experience of growing up. I did not have health insurance. My family didn't have health insurance. Did not grow up going to a physician, primary care, or otherwise. My father finally got health insurance through work when I was in high school. His first appointment, he was diagnosed with-- Malignant hypertension is what the doctor told him at the time. He ended up having a quadruple bypass within a month of having just newly acquired health insurance. All of these things that we had avoided or that we did not want to do. Culturally also, there was this idea that food is your medicine.

Ayurvedic treatments were the medicine. We did a lot of herbal stuff at home just because we had no access to anything else. He went from that to all of a sudden, at the most sort of invasive interventions that one can have. The whole concept of trust for me there was I always sort of was like, how did he allow this to happen? I still live with a lot of this. I don't go to the primary care doctor. I have a lot of some of that same avoidant behaviors, just because it's not something I grew up with. For my kids, they're at every single appointment, like and then some. For me, trust is reall what he thought was that he believed in the competence of this person that he was in the office with.

He believed that they had some knowledge, and he'd always say in our language, Sanskrit, "Vaidya." Vaid means doctor, which is essentially the knowledgeable one. He believed in their knowledge and their competence. The second piece I think was that they had integrity. If he showed up for an appointment, or when they said, "This is what's going to have to happen, this is the date you're going to show up, this is what we're going to do," they did it. They were very responsive to all of his questions. I think the other piece of it was they had a lot of compassion. They really showed him that they had his best interest at heart.

I think all of those pieces together, and underneath it all is really a relationship. He built this long-standing relationship, or he at least believed that he could in the beginning phases of that, where he felt like, these folks are going to be with me for the long haul, and they were. I think when trust breaks down is when you lose that belief that you have a relationship with this other person. It's really easy then to question their competence, or to question their compassion, or to question that they really care about you, or their integrity because they don't show up for me anyway.

I think that's how I see trust in medicine, and all of those pieces. Sorry, this is quite long-winded, but all of those pieces involve time. You have to have time in order to show that you have this foundation and to build this relationship. I think that's really how I see it, and that's how I've always tried to practice as a primary care provider as well. These are the three things that I have to provide you. Everything else is secondary in my mind.

Emily: I really appreciate what you said about growing up. This just wasn't a part of your family, a part of your culture, and now, as an adult with kids, like even for yourself, you still have some of those patterns from growing up that are entrenched. I was wondering, for both of you, maybe starting with your experience at the bedside, what are you seeing? What are people's fears? Where are the fears coming from? Is it a lack of access? Is it cost? Is it prior experiences that have been negative with gaslighting and things like that?

There's so many different drivers of not trusting medicine, and it expresses itself in a lot of different ways. Sometimes people will-- they'll be fine with a blood transfusion, but it's a hard no on vaccines. It's really interesting where the mistrust shows up. I'm just curious what you're seeing at the bedside these days, especially in the post-COVID era, where we can talk maybe about COVID later. That was a big rupture. What are you seeing on the ground?

Perry: All of the above. Different people have different reasons for distrusting medicine. There's obviously historical abuses still play into things for some people. On a meta level, what I see a lot of is frustration with the system, the way the system is structured, percolating down into the doctor-patient relationship. People see healthcare costs, their own and the nation's, spiraling out of control. They see rich insurance executives. They get denied medications that they had been prescribed for a long time. They see pharmaceutical companies charging hundreds of thousands of dollars per month for some medications.

That feels really icky. It feels wrong when it comes to healthcare. We in this country in particular, we've capitalized healthcare so much, but unlike other industries, people feel, I think deep down, that that's not the type of thing you should be profiting off of. I see a lot of that frustration coming down to the doctors. Are you ordering this test because it makes you more money? Are you ordering me this drug because you get kickbacks from the pharmaceutical company? Obviously, this came up with COVID with the vaccines as well. I really think it's a legitimate frustration with the system that people don't know who to complain to, in some sense, and it discolors all healthcare experiences.

A lot of times, it drives people to non-medical professionals for healthcare, which can result in some bad outcomes. These are places and people who are also making a profit off of patients, and oftentimes even not taking insurance and things like that. That structure is the same, but it's not so pervasive. It's not so overwhelming. It doesn't color the relationship the same way the doctor-patient relationship is covered by the morass of healthcare in the US.

Neha: A third, what has been said already, and I think that often I get the sense that after someone leaves, and this is my own experience in a primary, was this worth it? All of this waiting, all of this concern about what I'm actually fearing in the back of my mind, and I think a lot of patients will say that, like, "I'm coming in for a annual physical, but really I'm worried that my uncle was just diagnosed with cancer. I'm really worried about that." You've spent now 15, 20, 30 minutes checking a bunch of boxes. I waited eight months to have this appointment. It was canceled several times in between.

I'm leaving, feeling like, "I interacted with someone, but I didn't connect with anybody, and you didn't really ask any questions that pertain to what I was worried about." I think that people often leave feeling like that wasn't really worth it, worth my time, and it feels like a big waste. I think that that is a big-- I think all of those systemic, institutional reasons are why it often feels like that.

I'm speaking really in the primary care setting, but I think that that is a big hurdle to building trust, so that you can go upstream of conflict when it comes to vaccines, so that you can go upstream and figure out, "Hey, we're on the same page. We all want you to not get the flu this year or this flu season." "What is it that you think? This is why I think this." We can meet above the level of conflict, but we don't necessarily have the time to do that.

[music]

Emily: When you speak with patients and families, what is your sense for where they're getting their information? Do you find that people are turning to social media, social media influencers, certain personalities that they feel like they connect with whatever the quality of the information, they just happen to like this person, and it feels like it's their friend. That kind of thing. Do you find people going straight to the literature?

I definitely know some people like that who they like to go on PubMed by themselves. It's very difficult to interpret something as complex as the medical literature, you find one article. That can be tricky as well even if they're going to the primary data. What are you seeing? Where are people getting their info, and how is that showing up in the doctor-patient interaction?

Neha: I think for over a decade, there's definitely been internet sources, or that's definitely been something that people have come into the clinic with. I saw this on X, Y, and Z. Insert whatever website here. Now, more and more social media, even medical professional colleagues of mine, will say, "Oh, I follow this person, and I'm living by the 30:30:30 rule. I'm like, "What's that? Please share." I think there's a lot of that. I've definitely seen a lot more folks going to AI and just giving it the narrative of what's going on, and then saying, "Well, this is what needs to happen."

All of this information equals this one diagnosis and this one intervention. Yet, I really feel like what they want is for me to negate that, or to reassure them, or to say, "You know what? I can see why it's saying X, Y, and Z, but here's why. As I'm touching you, I'm not seeing this. I'm not feeling this. I'm not hearing this." You can feel a sense of calm when that happens. I think that's what people want, but what they get and where they're going is all of these other sources.

Perry: I certainly see similar. I think since the internet has existed, it's been possible for people to Google things, and patients continue to do that. I don't mind. I like an informed patient, someone who's learned some things. At least we have something to talk about. I have found that in the internet days, in the Google search days, prior to the AI days, there was also the possibility to engage confirmation bias by searching for what you want to be true. The truth is, the internet's very large. If you search for lung cancer cured, no chemo, you will find ample blogs and posts that say, "Oh yes, I didn't have to get chemo, and look, I'm lung cancer free."

The AI era has actually improved that a little bit. The AI models are trained well enough that if you push them in that direction, like, "Can I treat stage three lung cancer without chemotherapy or something like that?" They'll pretty much say no. Here are the current guidelines. Here's a link to the American Cancer Society, so on and so forth. I have actually seen that improve a little bit. People don't get quite as lost in rabbit holes. Then there's the social media. Most of the health questions I get around social media are generally people aren't searching for their own issue. It's, "I happened to see this, and it resonated with me."

You're not going on Instagram searching necessarily for lung cancer treatment. Most people aren't doing that, but you will be scrolling on Instagram and see someone who says, "Did you know that the number one cause of lung cancer in the United States isn't smoking? It's refined sugar or something." This is not true, listeners, by the way, but you'll see something like that, and you'll get questions about that. I agree with Neha.

Fortunately, if you're sitting in front of someone physically there, that does a tremendous amount of work if you can be present and not typing on the screen and looking over your shoulder to try to talk to the patient and if you're not rushing them through a five-minute appointment. The trust with the system is quite low. Most patients report that their trust with their individual doctors is quite a bit higher.

Emily: You mentioned that sometimes people will go to non-medical providers for different treatments and things like that. Sometimes that can be very expensive. It made me think about these other businesses. A lot of people express skepticism about the motives of big corporate hospital systems, the pharmaceutical industry and so on and so forth, but there is also big Wellness with a capital W.

You've got these health spas, you've got big vitamin, and all these supplements and things like that, which is its own profit-generating system. I'm wondering if you see people having similar skepticism toward that business as they have toward traditional medicine, or is there something about the alternative medicine world that just by virtue of being alternative, people give it a pass, or they're willing to trust it more?

Perry: That is mostly what I see is that people are so frustrated with the medical system that it doesn't matter what the alternative is. It's like voting in an election,

It's like, "Am I voting for this guy or am I really voting against that guy?" A lot of people are voting with their feet, sort of against the medical system. Now, there are lots of things the wellness places do a lot better, largely because they don't take insurance. They actually have very high margins, much higher than your typical hospital system in the US, which runs margins of about 3%. These wellness places, 20%, 30% profit margins, and what they'll do is they'll book you right away. They'll get you right in. That's something we're not great at. They'll spend time with you, 30-minute visits, 60-minute visits. The practitioners' part of their training is about listening.

Right now, they're listening like a good car salesman will listen, which is sort of like, "My goal is to sell you a car. I'm going to let you talk, and I'm going to wait until there's something I can hook onto that says, 'You know what would help is this great new car.'" It does mix these things, but the experience for the patient is, "Oh my gosh, I went to this office. It was clean, by the way. It was very nice. It was pretty. The lights were low. I had plenty of time to talk to this person. They seemed very empathetic.

In the end, I spent whatever $100 for the visit. I bought $50 worth of supplements." Is it any wonder that people feel better after that than coming to see me in a crowded clinic, and I walk in 30 minutes late because I've got too many patients to see, and they're out 10 minutes later with a prescription that costs $800 out of pocket before the insurance company pays for it? It's very hard to compete with that, even if what they're selling has no evidence, doesn't actually work, might be toxic, hasn't been vetted, is impure, and all these other problems,

Emily: Or just the human interaction itself-

Perry: Is therapeutic.

Emily: -serves a healing,

Perry: Absolutely.

Neha: I think that if just in Perry's early description of what they provide, in the intro to that, it is what we envisioned we would be providing our patients when we went into medical school. When we went into this field, it was to do exactly what Perry just said, which is to sit with someone, listen to them, let them speak, get curious, know what drives them, what motivates them, what excites them, what is fun for them, and also, as a byproduct, learn what may be going wrong. What are their fears? What are their concerns so that we can address them in an evidence-based way?

I think the other thing that people maybe feel like is lacking is sometimes common-sense ways as well within the healthcare system. Here's what I mean by that. I think that sometimes we talk a lot about the sandwich generation. I think healthcare professionals are in that sandwich in terms of we're the face of this institution that is making everything so difficult for patients. All of the things that you just described, the insurance companies, the big corporate health system, the enterprise-level health system made it so difficult. Now they finally have a face to that, so that's us, and we're toeing the line of trying to explain.

Well, yes, this is why, and trying to explain all that, which I don't think is wrong. That is the reality. Sometimes you do need the prior authorization because we have to start with this medication. I think sometimes you are forced to toe that line to explain what's going on, and then often people want the pill for the ill. When you're standing in the way of that and saying, "Well, here's the evidence, and here's why I don't think you need an antibiotic."

Again, it takes time. You have to have had a relationship with this person so they can swallow that pill and say, "Okay, I'm going to walk away without the prescription, but I know if in a few days I don't feel better, I can have access to this person again, and we can reassess." Because that is not there, this other alternative setting just becomes so attractive, and it is common sense in some way to say, "Hey, you are feeling sick. There's a lot of ways that we can make you feel better by shifting the food that you're eating, by increasing your exercise." It doesn'tstop there because then they also say, and you can take this pill to eliminate the fungus in your blood. I think--

Perry: Toxins. Yes. You got at something that is actually a bit of like a trust hack that I see particularly online and also in some of these wellness spaces, which is that humans have a cognitive bias that we're more likely to trust someone who seems certain, which is why if you do look on Instagram and look at wellness influencers and stuff, what you find is a great deal of rather extreme statements. These are the three foods in your pantry that will kill you. I actually saw one the other day that was-- farmed salmon is the most toxic food on earth. Just on the surface, there's a bunch of mushrooms that if you eat, you die within six hours, so it can't be the most toxic.

Not to mention pufferfish and sodium, but t. That hack works, and doctors, by training, won't do that. Nor should we, by the way, even when there's a clear-cut indication, and someone comes that they have community-acquired pneumonia, and we say, "We're going to put you on an antibiotic." That's what the evidence says. They say, "Am I going to feel better?" We say, "It won't eliminate the symptoms immediately, but it certainly will shorten the duration of symptoms and reduce infectivity."

We've been trained so much to couch the risk and benefit of everything that we do that it actually-- it's very hard to compete with people who say, "By the way, if you get this vaccine, you'll die within the next 12 months." Someone asks us that, and we say, "No, no, no. There's no, there's no evidence of that." Of course, nothing is risk-free. Of course, someone could have an anaphylactic reaction.

We always come back to that balance and nuance, and it's really hard to convey that and also build trust again if you don't have adequate time to do it, because otherwise, people who are scared are going to just flock to certainty. See, this guy seems to know what he's talking about. He seems pretty certain that you don't need chemotherapy for cancer. I like this guy, whereas we say, "Well, the studies show that on average, chemotherapy improves life expectancy." That kind of stuff. It's a real it's a real problem.

Neha: Sorry, just to add to that piece. I think the converse sometimes is also true where we convey a lot of certainty in our expertise and our expert opinion, and then there's a big practice-changing study that comes out, and we have not built in the humility to how we talk to people and how we should-- I think we're very well trained at, "Oh yes. I can't say with complete certainty," but sometimes we also come at people, particularly at an institutional expert level, with this, "If you don't do this, you are not following the science, and you are wrong."

I think that's very hard to convey the message of, "Here's the best knowledge that we have so far, and we are going to continue to ensure that we're providing you with the best knowledge based on these additional studies. Sometimes things might change, and that's only because we are trying to give you the newer recommendation based on the newest, best available science." I think we sometimes fall down on that side as well.

Perry: On the public communication side, absolutely. I think one-on-one with a doctor, you tend to get the nuance. It's people like us, Neha, who are talking to a broad population of people, we're trying to keep it simple. We've got messaging that we want people to understand. Like the MMR vaccine does not cause autism. We have these things that-- There's, I think, a tendency, and I think this is actually where some of the public health messaging in COVID went wrong, that because you see that the messaging on the other side, these vaccines will kill you within 30 days.

Which you'll recall, there was that when the vaccines were first getting rolled out, like it's going to be a mass extinction event. You have people saying it's going to be a mass extinction event, this vaccine rollout. I think it was very hard for public health officials in that setting to not lean heavily in the other direction, just so that there's a net balance. I think that was probably a mistake, and in the end, I think conveying a little more of the actual uncertainty around things would have worked better. It's really hard to do when you have someone standing next to you screaming the extreme statement.

Neha: Absolutely.

Emily: I was going to ask about this concept of medical reversals. At The Nocturnists, we spoke to a physician, Dr. Adam Sifu, who I think wrote a book that's just called Medical Reversal. We were talking to a pediatrician earlier today about how, with infants sleeping, first it was on their tummy, and then it was on their side, and then it was on their back, and the guidelines kept changing, or peanut exposure, it was like, "Don't give them peanuts," and then it was like, "Just kidding. Give them peanuts as soon as you can." With COVID, obviously, there was a number of medical reversals that happened in a very short, compressed period of time.

In the menopause community, there's a lot of conversations about the medical reversals related to hormone replacement therapy, "It's going to give you a heart attack. Just kidding." Do we need to do a better job communicating to the public that science is alive and it's evolving? What do we say to people who see these pendulum swings and then they're just like, "I'm out," you guys don't know what you're talking about. I'm going to drink my [crosstalk] raw milk.

Yes, exactly. With nutrition, and some of it is agenda-driven and profit-driven. We've learned a lot about big sugar and how in the '90s everything was about being low-fat, but it was packed with sugar, and now we're realizing that the sugar is harmful. It's like, "Well, where did that narrative come from?" You start to get into some of these more systemic issues. How do you think about that, and how do you talk to patients about that?

Neha: I think that this is very difficult in the primary care setting as well. Certainly at the health communication level, when you're talking at the population level, but even in the clinic, and I think that what I usually err on is sort of like the 80:20 rule. There is 80% of what we know, which is very much there is a consensus around. This is particularly around conversations around food and nutrition. It's not a surprise what a healthy plate looks like. Now, we can play around at the margins, and it's constantly evolving whether or not 1 egg, 10 eggs, what is going to cause disease or worsen your health.

We can play around with this, but 80% of what is going to keep you healthy-- we know for a fact that it's going to be fruits, vegetables, whole grains. This is where I think the common-sense piece, where we have to meet people where they believe that food and nutrition plays a major role in their health. They want us to talk about that. I think that we have to address that. They believe that environmental pollution impacts their health. We have to acknowledge that in what we're saying.

Now we can say that, but there is an evolving literature around some of the edges, so some of the specifics may change. As soon as we have that evidence, we're going to talk to you about how these things might change. That's how I do it in my clinic, one-on-one.

Perry: I think that's incredibly well said. It's worth highlighting that most of medicine is pretty consistent over time, but you don't hear about that in the news because that's not interesting. It's not interesting to say anymore that smoking causes lung cancer. What would be interesting is if a study came out that said smoking doesn't cause lung cancer, and that'll get 8 million headlines and a bunch of patients calling us, being like, "What were you talking about?" Nevertheless, these things do happen, and I try to convey to patients. Really, when I'm teaching the med students and residents critical appraisal of the literature, is that in medicine, evidence has a weight.

There's a weight of evidence, and it accumulates over time on one side of the scale, and it's the best we have. In some cases, we have little weight on either side, and it's leaning this way. Who really knows? In some cases, we have a lot of weight, but things could still change in the future. When I'm talking to patients, I try to describe, "This is a feature, not a bug. "What makes science different from religion is that there's nothing set in stone. We continue to learn, and you want people to do this. We learn how to do studies better. We learn how to enroll a more representative population.

Even things that are biologically true may behave differently over time as the makeup of the population changes, as the comorbidities change. We should expect it to evolve, and we should support the research that adds weight to one side of the scale or another. When your doctor says, "Oh, by the way, remember I told you never eat an egg again because eggs raise cholesterol." Well, more recent data suggests it's not that big a deal, and there's a lot of good stuff in eggs, so go ahead. The response should be, "Oh, great. I'm glad someone studied that and didn't just take it for granted because it was written in a book somewhere." That's what makes medicine--

Neha: I think this is where there's also value sometimes to social media. Hear me out, and what I mean by this is when you're seeing a signal in patient complaints around something. I'm thinking specifically around IUD insertion, and you had a lot of women saying that that was the worst process of my life. I had so much pain, and the counseling at the time of insertion was, "Oh, it's fine. You should be fine. Here's a pain reliever, if you need it." I think what we have to do-- again, this comes back to humility and recognizing that yes, science is constantly evolving, and we need patient voices also to help us understand the direction of what we're studying. Yes, go ahead, sorry.

Perry: This is so critical. So many of the enduring health-related conspiracy theories. If you trace the history back, you find exactly this: a real story of patients not being listened to. We recently, on our podcast, were talking about ticks. It's tick season in Connecticut. There's lots of fun tick diseases to talk about, but we dug into the history of Lyme disease, and as you probably know, there is a lot of information and disinformation and misinformation about Lyme disease out there. A lot of controversy. Obviously RFK Jr. has opinions. He mentioned it was a bioweapon.

There's all sorts of stuff, but if you go back in time to when Lyme disease was discovered, late '60s, early '70s, what you had was a group of moms in Lyme, Connecticut, whose kids had all been diagnosed with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, and they went to their doctors and were like, "All our kids can't have JRA. This is a rare condition. Why do they all have it? They're all the same age," whatever. The doctor said, "No, no, no. It's juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. Look at the swollen knee," whatever. Until eventually, someone took these moms seriously and said, "Maybe there's something else." This was actually done at Yale.

Borrelia burgdorferi, that spirochete that causes Lyme disease, was discovered and could be treated and so on and so forth. I believe that those origin stories of things, the COVID vaccine isn't too different. Percolate down through history, even among people who don't know that story, it somehow persists, and we still have to deal with that stuff. To the extent that we can actually listen to patients about what they're telling us, doctors 20 years from now will thank us because this whole ecosystem of alternate science won't have a chance to develop if we actually do the right science at the beginning. That's all.

[music]

Emily: I love what you said, Neha, about looking for signals in the population, because oftentimes when it's a one-on-one interaction between a clinician and a patient, it's relatively easy in a just human interaction to get underneath the fear, figure out what is this really about. Is it really about a blood transfusion, or is it really about this other thing that happened to you four years ago, and that's driving this? Usually, with a conversation or a couple conversations, you can get at what's really going on, but it's like, how do you do that at a population level? With Lyme, it's like, "Well, what's really going on?"

Actually, the root of this comes from a mass distrust event. I'm wondering if that's a fertile ground for new research. Especially with social media and AI and just big data. Wouldn't it be interesting if we could put sensors or antennas around, like in Twitter or whatever, in TikTok, and just get like a weather report. Like every week or every month or every year. What are people talking about? What's bothering them? What are their fears? Where is their mistrust located? Almost like population-level couples therapy. It's like, "Was your fight really about the burrito in the fridge, or was it about something else?" Can we do that at a mass scale? Does that does that even make sense?

Neha: I love that. You hit on something that I think is so important in the clinic, which is that you get to pilot test your messaging and recalibrate in real time as you're talking to someone because you get their facial movement, or they're leaning in or they're leaning out. You can say, "This tack that I'm taking is not working. I've got to adjust. I've got to figure out what is going to actually connect with this patient." You have the space and the ability to do that when you're one-on-one with someone, or in a group visit. I think that's a very interesting idea.

I do feel like that's where a lot of evidence is coming from, where you percolate these messages or percolating, and then it's on us. I think it's really interesting, Perry, what you said that you've noticed this in social media. These messages around the wellness industry, so you created a podcast to try to address some of the main questions that you are hearing. Is that how you came up with this concept of your podcast?

Perry: Yes, absolutely. It was just sort of the idea. You can say in a minute and 30 seconds of a clip on Instagram, you can generate about 45 minutes' worth of things to debunk, basically. Not everything out there is fake either. There's some people giving great advice, and actually, there's some great science communicators on Instagram. Particularly when it comes to diet and stuff like that, I love a good Instagram recipe. It's like it's quick. You see people making the pan these healthy things. They're high protein, whatever. What was missing? I felt like, and it's not for everyone. It's for people who actually want to listen for an hour.

What was missing was what's the data behind this claim? What we find-- there's some big themes that keep emerging. We pick one topic a week, but there's some big themes that emerge. One is that there's a dramatic overreliance on biological plausibility. Wellness influencers will say, "Did you know that one of the proteins in the electron transport chain changes conformation in response to 580-nanometer red light? Therefore, if you put red light on your skin, it will reduce your wrinkles." There's this leap from this actually true fact to this clinical outcome. As a researcher, I know that I'm not allowed to do that.

I have to have a hypothesis that has some basis in fact, and then I have to design an experiment to test whether it leads the outcome. We wanted to bring to light that process and say, "Here's what's true. Sure, if you isolate this protein in a petri dish and you shoot a laser at it, this is what actually happens. Now here's what happens when you try it in mice. Here's what happens when you try it in humans. Here's what it costs. Here's who's making money off of this and not." For some things, we'll come down and be like, yes, this seems good. We did a whole creatine episode and dug through all the randomized trial data.

In the end, at least for people trying to build some muscle, seems pretty good. There's some decent data here. The weight of evidence leans in this direction, and then for some stuff, obviously, it's on the other side. We felt like there needed to be someone doing fact-checking and explaining the science underneath it all, because actually the science is I think is the coolest part. Teaching people how to think scientifically again, as opposed to with their gut, is maybe the er goal of the whole podcast.

Neha: I think, Emily, what you said also is really interesting in terms of directing research questions as well. This again, I'll be very anecdotal. I remember in med school, so as I mentioned, growing up, the things that my parents did were yoga, deep breathing exercises. This is what the foundation and everyone in my community was doing that. We had a lecture on heart disease, and this is about 20 years ago or so.

I went to the professor, and I was like, "Yes, what do you think about yoga as an intervention?" That is just woo woo, new age banana stuff, and then it took us being able to have fMRI studies and to take this 1,000s of year old tradition and be able to say, "Yes, the science show. Yes science. Yes, it does have benefits." I think we also need to have some humility in terms of what kinds of questions we're asking.

Where are we sort of-- Is this culturally competent in terms of what we'll give funding to, or where we'll spend our time investigating? I think that those are also pieces that we need to be thinking about as clinicians, because these are the things that people are asking in the clinic. Should I do-- but you're doing [unintelligible 00:49:06]? Now we have more evidence, but we didn't always answer that question in a way that was culturally competent, I think, or responsive to what people were seeing in their communities.

Emily: Yes, I think learning how to attune to the public, or I guess a cruder way of saying it, is like read the room. I'm just thinking about the vaccine autism scenario. I interviewed a pediatrician who was talking about moms and just how they were more afraid of autism than they were of measles for whatever reason. Maybe it's because the vaccine has been so effective there just isn't a lot of measles around. If you haven't seen it, you're not afraid of it. Maybe it's because when they were growing up, measles was normal, and people had measles parties and to inoculate each other.

To them, that was part of their culture, and it just didn't scare them that much. Even though there is a subset of kids who get very, very ill and who can die from that, it was rare enough. If you scale it to a population level, that's a lot of dead kids. If you're just in your family or in your community, maybe you don't see that. The fear isn't as visceral, whereas we do have rising rates of autism, and people see that everywhere, and they're terrified. Why isn't there more research on autism? I think when RFK started to talk about autism and say "Oh, we're going to pour all this money into it." Whatever his motives, whatever his misinformation, people felt seen.

Perry: Good.

Emily: I'm wondering, yeah, like what you think about how the health research and medical industry can attune better to the public and read the room and figure out what's actually concerning people, and how are people talking about that right now?

Perry: There's a lot of ways that research can be done better, and that's a major one. I think it is the NIH and the government sources of funding that will really have to be the place that these questions get answered. Pharmaceutical companies might have deep pockets, but they're really designed to identify and treat diseases, not particularly to prevent disease. Although, we have preventative drugs, we have statins, we have vaccines, and things, but they're all still tied to a disease-based outcome like MI. The public and the wellness industry leans into this is interested in maintaining health. They're interested in health span.

How long can I live and be functional and happy and do the things I want to do? Everyone wants that to be as long as possible. there's no pharmaceutical company that can even design a trial with a drug to test that because it wouldn't be long enough, and who knows how you'd even start biologically. It is the place for government funders to listen to the people. We're their employers, so they say. To listen to the people. What are we worried about? Preserving cognition. Yes, we're worried about childhood development.

We're not just in autism, which we of course are, but we're worried about childhood development in the age of phones and social media and rapid videos and all these kind of things. There's not many sources of funding to study that stuff. The NIH, for a long time, and the medical research community have been disease-focused. Name your disease. The NIH is full of centers that are based on diseases. My I apply for grants from the National Institutes of Diabetes, Digestive, and Kidney Disease.

It's all oriented that way, and that's fine. By the way, we've done such an amazing job at reducing the burden of disease over the past 100 years in medical research, but maintaining health is a bigger challenge, and one that's probably not going to be driven by some cool new pharmaceutical product. I don't know, maybe GLP ones. No, it's going to be based on lifestyle changes. I think people are desperate for those studies to be done at high quality, and I am encouraged to see people like RFK at least nodding in that direction. Although, yes, I know that some of his pre-held beliefs might color the direction that funding goes.

Neha: I think this again gets to trust, which is that you. I completely agree with you. I think the vast majority, if we're talking 80:20 again, that people want to be healthy. They want their healthcare system to lean into health and not into waiting, waiting, waiting until you're sick. Blood pressure, heart rate, a lot of the vitals that we check are lagging indicators of once that has shifted, you're in some disease state potentially once you're diagnosed with hypertension, but people want to be able to catch this, or that they're on some trajectory to that beforehand, so that they can make the lifestyle change.

We can see that there is a need, and there is a motivation for people. They do want to change in some way. I don't know that necessarily it's that people don't want to change their habits. It's just that they want to be told, "If I do this one thing," then everything will change. I think that's where we do need high-quality studies to show how do all of these lifestyle pieces work together with nutrition, with sleep. How does that work in tandem with physical activity so that we can keep you and your child-- I think children, having children, is a major motivating factor for people, and I think that's why they're look-- You have the MAHA movement that's really looking at environmental exposures.

Now, we might not necessarily agree with the agenda or what they're necessarily thinking is the underlying cause, so it's not vaccines, but something is happening in terms of earlier diagnoses of colon cancers and other. We have to acknowledge, and we have to say-- I think your point is so well taken, Perry, is that this is a question that we, our government, is going to answer, and here's how much money we're investing, and it's going to be health-focused, not necessarily disease-focused. I think we have to say that very clearly.

Emily: I was thinking about some of the people we interviewed on the street when we were doing research on this, and we interviewed all sorts of people, just all socioeconomic status, and one pattern that came up a little bit, especially from the people who were really low socioeconomic status, out of care, that we heard a couple of times is like parasites. That was a word that kept coming up. I remember there was this one woman; she was like smoking a cigarette outside of the Walmart, and she said, "Well, our bodies are infested with parasites, and the doctors don't even want to touch that. They don't even want to look at that.

They pretend that doesn't exist. What about all these parasites?" I think it can be easy to just blow that off and say that person clearly has no idea what they're talking about, and that's a conspiracy theory or whatever. You look at the news, and it's like headlines about plastics. Plastics have been found in the testicles of men. Plastics have been found in the placenta of pregnant women, and why aren't we talking about that? Some of this stuff around food dyes and like this stuff that's just in the environment, why aren't we talking about that? It just made me think about the parasites thing.

Obviously those aren't the same, but there is a little bit of an underlying theme, which is instead of medicine reacting once I've already developed a disease, what about the water we swim in, and what about some of these environmental exposures and lifestyle things? Neha, you have special training in lifestyle medicine, so I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on that. When I was in med school, we didn't really learn about nutrition at all. Do you think that medicine needs to evolve to start to encompass some of these topics and take them more seriously?

Neha: Yes, I absolutely do. I think that movement is already happening. We have residency programs that are focusing on lifestyle medicine, we have fellowships that are focusing on lifestyle medicine across the country. I think we really have to be thinking about it in the same way we think about any other intervention. What is the dose? What is that intensive therapeutic lifestyle intervention that is actually going to make a difference in terms of prevention, in terms of management? If we look at the guidelines of a vast majority of chronic diseases, whether it's hypertension or diabetes or even chronic kidney disease, lifestyle intervention is that throwaway line at the bottom.

I think oftentimes, we think that our patients are just not going to be interested in that. That they want really the medication, or they're going to wait until there's something where they feel sick before they make the change. I know I see it in my clinic and the people that I talk to, they, I think, though, are thinking about it as a medication. They're like, "What is the dose of fiber that I need? How much fiber exactly? How many blueberries do I need to eat so that I don't get dementia?" I think we have to have a curriculum that helps us understand again that this is a dietary pattern. What is the pattern? How do we prescribe that pattern? I keep seeing media reports of, "Exercise in a pill. If you take this pill, it's the same amount. You'll have all--

Neha: If only.

Emily: It's like how do we actually prescribe the exercise, and how do we have this curriculum on behavior change? In medicine, I think we often don't do things unless we do a test, and then we can change our management based on the test, and so we don't necessarily ask about some of these things because we don't necessarily know how to change our management.

We don't have teams of nutritionists, and mental health professionals, or behavioral health professionals that will help us do this because it's not all on the physician to do all of this. This is very much a team-based sport. I think we haven't necessarily leaned into it because we don't have the supporting cast necessarily that's also trained to do this in the way that is going to be the right therapeutic intervention to show a difference to maintain health.

When it comes to the microplastics, I think that is so interesting. My husband's a gastroenterologist, and he says the number of people that come in with outside testing that that says, "Here's my fungal count and here's my parasite level. Do something about this." He's just like, "Why did you pay for this test?" I think we have to figure out a way of talking about environmental exposures because we don't yet have the evidence, I think, to Perry's point for some of these things. In my clinic, I think about it in the framing of the precautionary principle. Just because I don't know, I think that there is enough evidence of microplastics and cardiovascular disease.

I think we need to acknowledge and say we don't know all of the answers yet. This gets to Perry's point about this is evolving. This science is evolving. I understand. I agree, this is a concern. Here are ways that you can minimize plastic exposure, and we're still learning the extent to which this is going to impact your health, but this is the common sense part of it. People are worried. Again, this gets to what Perry said earlier. Biologic plausibility. We don't want to go all in as physicians and say, Yes, microplastics are causing everything." I think we do have to meet people where they are and where they want to make the change.

Perry: I'm thinking through the implications.

Emily: Yes, please. I'm very curious.

Perry: Lifestyle modification is difficult for many reasons. All humans are creatures of habit. We did a randomized trial here once in patients with heart failure about a bunch of different digital health devices to improve their well-being. The one that worked the best for our outcome, which was like a heart failure quality of life score, was the one they liked using the least. [laughs] It was because it was the one that forced them to do stuff. Annoyed them to get up and walk, and annoyed them to take their medication. It wasn't pleasant, and it just drilled home to me, like, "Huh. Sometimes the most effective things are the things that don't come naturally to us," right?

We have to actually make changes. I think we also have to recognize, and this is part of building trust in a culturally sensitive way, how difficult lifestyle changes can be for some people in this country just based on the circumstances of their life. It's great to say, "Oh, fresh meats and produce," but if you don't have a car, and the closest supermarket is five miles away, that's just not going to happen.

I think one of the concerns I have actually about the MAHA movement and wellness in general is that it's hyper-individualistic. In its worst incarnation, it says everything that's wrong with you is your own fault, right? Like you ate the wrong food, you didn't drink the right milk. You did all this stuff, and that's why you're having this problem, but don't worry, because if you change it all, this problem will go away.

I think it is important for us all to remember how much of health outcomes on a population level are driven by policy and not individual choice. Maybe this is me being cynical, but I do worry that some of the hyper-individualistic, "It's all on you to get yourself better, or to get yourself sick," will lead to further decreases in trust of public health interventions. I think they're somehow tied together almost. That it's like, we don't need Big Brother government coming down and telling us what to do.

Fixing the water supply, or providing free vaccinations, or things like that, because as long as you eat these appropriate supplements, you're going to be fine. I'm not saying this is 100% how it works, but it is something I just want to have out there that we have a duty when we're communicating to the public, to also remember to communicate to people who are in charge of policy, and that those decisions can have really wide-ranging impacts.

Neha: I think that's one area where I am somewhat optimistic in that we have a very robust insurance system that covers insulin or diabetes medication, but not necessarily one that will give you a produce prescription.

Perry: Chicken breast. [chuckles]

Neha: Or one that will give you access to a gym. That's just not something that we prescribe. It'll be a fun thing to write on your prescription pad and be like, "Ah, exercise three-- here you go." The actual funding of that, we don't necessarily do. I think that is a key point in terms of if you're going to consider this a prescription, it has to be accessible at a population level. Yes, I fully agree with that.

Emily: Well, we've covered a lot of ground so far. I feel like we could keep going for another hour, but I know our time is limited, so as we bring this to a close, Neha and Perry, wondering if there's any final thoughts, final words about trust in medicine, things that the medical community could do better, or suggestions for how to get good information, or just any final thoughts to close us out.

Perry: I'll just say that if you want to know the number one surefire way to lose that stubborn belly fat, you can subscribe to my [inaudible 01:05:59]

[laughter]

Emily: For the low, low price.

Perry: I was testing everyone to see if they were paying attention. No, I think I'm so glad that we had the opportunity to talk about this. The one take-home for me here is trust takes time. Trust takes communication. We had some time here. We got to communicate. I hope people can hear some of the things that we're saying and bring them back to their own practices. If you're a healthcare professional, or their own relationships, if you're not, so thanks for having me on.

Neha: I thank you for the opportunity to have this conversation. I fully agree with Perry. I think the only additional piece I think that we didn't necessarily talk about is recognizing that these physicians that want so badly, or health professionals that want so badly, to have these trusting relationships with their patients, are also operating in systems where efficiency means something very different to the people that are in charge of the systems.

I don't want to necessarily end on a negative note, but I think that we do need to think about systems where physicians are seen somewhat as widgets, or cogs in a wheel that have to move people through in this efficient manner to address metrics like access and other things when we really need to shift what metric is it that's most important to us. I think if we're really in an age where people are losing trust in healthcare professionals and institutions, then maybe we need to think about changing those underlying metrics.

Really get back to what worked optimally before, which was having time with someone that you had a relationship with, so that when there are changes in the science, or the literature, you can go back to this person and trust that what they are recommending for you is based on their interest in your health, and that they're doing this with compassion and the best knowledge available at that time.

Emily: I think that's a good note to end on. I think that's a positive note, something to strive for and to aim for. I have been speaking with Dr. Neha Pathik and Dr. Perry Wilson. This has been really fun. I've really enjoyed speaking with both of you. I hope the audience will check out both of you and your writing, and your work, and your podcast, Perry, with Emily Oster. That sounds like a great resource. Thank you so much for doing this and for having this conversation.

Neha: Thank you so much.

Perry: Sure. Thanks.


Transcript

Note: The Nocturnists is an audio-first experience with emotion and sound design that can be difficult to fully capture in text. Transcripts are provided to support accessibility and reference, but may contain minor inaccuracies. If quoting in print, please consult the audio when possible.

Emily Silverman: You're listening to The Nocturnists. I'm Emily Silverman. What makes us trust our doctors? Is it their knowledge, their experience, the way they listen, or simply the feeling that they have our best interests at heart? What happens when that trust begins to break down? Today, we're partnering with Medscape Medical News as part of their editorial initiative, Healing a Broken Trust, which examines the erosion of public trust in medicine and science, and what it might take to rebuild it. This is a subject we've been thinking about a lot at The Nocturnists as we work on our new podcast documentary series, Trust in Medicine, slated for release in the spring of 2027.

For today's conversation, I'm joined by two physicians who spend a lot of time thinking about how medical information reaches the public. Dr. Neha Pathik is an internist, lifestyle medicine physician, and chief physician editor for Health and Lifestyle Medicine at WebMD. Dr. Perry Wilson is a nephrologist, researcher, author, and science communicator at Yale.

Together, we explore why patients are increasingly turning to social media, AI, and the wellness industry for answers. What traditional medicine can learn from these alternatives, and why even the best scientific evidence can fall short when patients don't feel heard. We also talk about medical reversals, the challenge of communicating uncertainty, and the importance of making space for patients' questions, fears, and experiences. Take a listen to my conversation with Neha and Perry.

[music]

Emily: I am Dr. Emily Silverman. I'm an internal medicine physician and the creator and host of The Nocturnists Medical Storytelling Podcast, and I am sitting here today with Dr. Neha Pathak and Dr. Perry Wilson to talk about trust in medicine. Neha and Perry, thank you so much for coming on.

Neha Pathik: Thanks so much.

Perry Wilson: Thanks for having us.

Emily: Before we dive in, I just wanted to share a little bit with the audience about each of you and who you are. Neha, you are WebMD's chief physician editor for health and lifestyle medicine, trained in internal medicine and lifestyle medicine, on faculty at the Atlanta VA Medical Center's Quality Scholars Program, an adjunct assistant professor of medicine at Emory, and a lecturer at the Yale School of Public Health.

You also host WebMD's podcast Health Discovered. Perry, you are a nationally recognized physician, researcher, educator, and writer who has a weekly video series on Medscape's Impact Factor from 2018 through August 2026, which breaks down new research for clinicians. You're also an associate professor at the Yale School of Medicine and director of clinical and translational research. You're also the author of How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't: Learning Who to Trust to Get and Stay Healthy.

Obviously, that's very relevant to our conversation today. To dive in, I'd love to hear each of you speak a little bit about your clinical life, and then a little bit about your life as a public communicator because both of you do both. You see patients, and you also speak to the public. Tell us a little bit about what that looks like for each of you.

Neha: I can start. I am essentially a primary care doctor who focuses on lifestyle medicine. My clinical work has been mostly within the VA healthcare system, where I also do a lot of quality improvement within the VA, so quality improvement work. Outside of the VA, I volunteer at a free clinic for undocumented patients, refugees, and those who do not have health insurance. I started working in health communication when my patients would come into the office and say that they were very scared about something because they read something on WebMD, and it told them that they had X, Y,, and Z condition.

Initially, that would be very distressing for me as a primary care doctor, where I was like, "Well, why aren't you listening to me? Why are you listening to WebMD?" I would have them bring in this information. When I read it, it seemed actually completely properly sourced. It seemed very accurate. It seemed like it was very balanced, and that it didn't really lead someone to think that they had X, Y, and Z most extreme condition. That's when I started to realize people are concerned about something.

They're not telling me what that is, and they're confirming their worst fear online or through social media. It's my job to understand what that is and communicate it in a way when I'm one-on-one with a patient or when I'm talking sort of more at a population level through writings in the media or on social media, in a way that is nuanced, accurate, but also allowing people to say, "I get that, but this is the thing that I'm the most scared about. Help me understand why it's not this." I think that's really what led me to come to WebMD to work here and to try to do that in the clinic, but also on a more sort of broader scale level.

Emily: Great. Perry?

Perry: Well, I'm a nephrologist by training. I'm a kidney doctor. That means I see people with chronic kidney disease, acute kidney injury in the hospital, spend a fair amount of time in the intensive care unit. The joke is no one's ever happy to see the kidney doctor walk into their room at the hospital. That's my clinical experience. That's probably 25% of my time. 75% is clinical research. I run a research program here at Yale that does a lot of clinical trials, research with electronic health record data.

My training was really in that world of statistics and trial design and biases and confounding and all of those things that we learn and teach in medical school, critical appraisal of the literature. I find that stuff really interesting. I know a lot of people think it's boring, but I think those types of errors that doctors make in interpreting the literature was how I initially got interested in public communication, started working with Medscape on Impact Factor, which is really directed towards healthcare providers in that language and at that level.

More recently, I wanted to expand out a little bit more to the general population, which led to this book for the lay public called How Medicine Works and When It Doesn't, which really tries to explore where we go wrong as doctors and how we fail our patients, often not through lack of knowledge or errors or poor diagnosis, but through failure to establish trust. Most recently, trying to do some real data-driven exploration of wellness trends, which are taking over our outpatient population based on Instagram and TikTok and stuff like that.

I have a new podcast with Emily Ostrer called Wellness Actually, which explores a topic ranging from creatine supplementation to red light therapy to declining sperm counts and all this kind of stuff, and actually digs into is there any data to support what the people online are telling you? It's what keeps me sane in between dealing with prior authorizations and other hassles of being a doctor in the modern era.

Emily: There's so much I want to ask you both about what you just said, but before I do, I wanted to just start with something really basic, which is just to talk about trust as a concept. I was telling some of the other folks we were talking to earlier today that here at The Nocturnists, we're working on an audio podcast documentary series on trust in medicine. As part of our research, we went out into the street with a microphone and just asked random people, people on a college campus, people at the mall, people at Walmart, "What is trust? What is trust to you? What does trust mean?" I was wondering how each of you think about that word, trust. What is it and what does it mean?

Neha: Go ahead, Perry. I'll let you go. We can ping-pong back and forth.

Perry: Yes. I think we all kind of have a sense of it, but it's hard to put it in words. For me, it's the willingness to do something you wouldn't otherwise do because of your belief or faith in another person. Fundamentally, when it comes to our interactions with patients, where things don't get gummed up, is when we're all in agreement, and everyone wants to quit smoking, and you want them to quit smoking.

Then it's less of a trust issue, and it's more of a knowledge issue. What are the best pathways, and how do we do this? Trust really comes up when there's a discrepancy there, when you're saying, "I'm asking you to make a change that you might not have made otherwise, and you may not even believe that it works." That's the hardest part of medicine where we often fall short. What do you think, Neha?

Neha: I reflect on trust with sort of my lived experience of growing up. I did not have health insurance. My family didn't have health insurance. Did not grow up going to a physician, primary care, or otherwise. My father finally got health insurance through work when I was in high school. His first appointment, he was diagnosed with-- Malignant hypertension is what the doctor told him at the time. He ended up having a quadruple bypass within a month of having just newly acquired health insurance. All of these things that we had avoided or that we did not want to do. Culturally also, there was this idea that food is your medicine.

Ayurvedic treatments were the medicine. We did a lot of herbal stuff at home just because we had no access to anything else. He went from that to all of a sudden, at the most sort of invasive interventions that one can have. The whole concept of trust for me there was I always sort of was like, how did he allow this to happen? I still live with a lot of this. I don't go to the primary care doctor. I have a lot of some of that same avoidant behaviors, just because it's not something I grew up with. For my kids, they're at every single appointment, like and then some. For me, trust is reall what he thought was that he believed in the competence of this person that he was in the office with.

He believed that they had some knowledge, and he'd always say in our language, Sanskrit, "Vaidya." Vaid means doctor, which is essentially the knowledgeable one. He believed in their knowledge and their competence. The second piece I think was that they had integrity. If he showed up for an appointment, or when they said, "This is what's going to have to happen, this is the date you're going to show up, this is what we're going to do," they did it. They were very responsive to all of his questions. I think the other piece of it was they had a lot of compassion. They really showed him that they had his best interest at heart.

I think all of those pieces together, and underneath it all is really a relationship. He built this long-standing relationship, or he at least believed that he could in the beginning phases of that, where he felt like, these folks are going to be with me for the long haul, and they were. I think when trust breaks down is when you lose that belief that you have a relationship with this other person. It's really easy then to question their competence, or to question their compassion, or to question that they really care about you, or their integrity because they don't show up for me anyway.

I think that's how I see trust in medicine, and all of those pieces. Sorry, this is quite long-winded, but all of those pieces involve time. You have to have time in order to show that you have this foundation and to build this relationship. I think that's really how I see it, and that's how I've always tried to practice as a primary care provider as well. These are the three things that I have to provide you. Everything else is secondary in my mind.

Emily: I really appreciate what you said about growing up. This just wasn't a part of your family, a part of your culture, and now, as an adult with kids, like even for yourself, you still have some of those patterns from growing up that are entrenched. I was wondering, for both of you, maybe starting with your experience at the bedside, what are you seeing? What are people's fears? Where are the fears coming from? Is it a lack of access? Is it cost? Is it prior experiences that have been negative with gaslighting and things like that?

There's so many different drivers of not trusting medicine, and it expresses itself in a lot of different ways. Sometimes people will-- they'll be fine with a blood transfusion, but it's a hard no on vaccines. It's really interesting where the mistrust shows up. I'm just curious what you're seeing at the bedside these days, especially in the post-COVID era, where we can talk maybe about COVID later. That was a big rupture. What are you seeing on the ground?

Perry: All of the above. Different people have different reasons for distrusting medicine. There's obviously historical abuses still play into things for some people. On a meta level, what I see a lot of is frustration with the system, the way the system is structured, percolating down into the doctor-patient relationship. People see healthcare costs, their own and the nation's, spiraling out of control. They see rich insurance executives. They get denied medications that they had been prescribed for a long time. They see pharmaceutical companies charging hundreds of thousands of dollars per month for some medications.

That feels really icky. It feels wrong when it comes to healthcare. We in this country in particular, we've capitalized healthcare so much, but unlike other industries, people feel, I think deep down, that that's not the type of thing you should be profiting off of. I see a lot of that frustration coming down to the doctors. Are you ordering this test because it makes you more money? Are you ordering me this drug because you get kickbacks from the pharmaceutical company? Obviously, this came up with COVID with the vaccines as well. I really think it's a legitimate frustration with the system that people don't know who to complain to, in some sense, and it discolors all healthcare experiences.

A lot of times, it drives people to non-medical professionals for healthcare, which can result in some bad outcomes. These are places and people who are also making a profit off of patients, and oftentimes even not taking insurance and things like that. That structure is the same, but it's not so pervasive. It's not so overwhelming. It doesn't color the relationship the same way the doctor-patient relationship is covered by the morass of healthcare in the US.

Neha: A third, what has been said already, and I think that often I get the sense that after someone leaves, and this is my own experience in a primary, was this worth it? All of this waiting, all of this concern about what I'm actually fearing in the back of my mind, and I think a lot of patients will say that, like, "I'm coming in for a annual physical, but really I'm worried that my uncle was just diagnosed with cancer. I'm really worried about that." You've spent now 15, 20, 30 minutes checking a bunch of boxes. I waited eight months to have this appointment. It was canceled several times in between.

I'm leaving, feeling like, "I interacted with someone, but I didn't connect with anybody, and you didn't really ask any questions that pertain to what I was worried about." I think that people often leave feeling like that wasn't really worth it, worth my time, and it feels like a big waste. I think that that is a big-- I think all of those systemic, institutional reasons are why it often feels like that.

I'm speaking really in the primary care setting, but I think that that is a big hurdle to building trust, so that you can go upstream of conflict when it comes to vaccines, so that you can go upstream and figure out, "Hey, we're on the same page. We all want you to not get the flu this year or this flu season." "What is it that you think? This is why I think this." We can meet above the level of conflict, but we don't necessarily have the time to do that.

[music]

Emily: When you speak with patients and families, what is your sense for where they're getting their information? Do you find that people are turning to social media, social media influencers, certain personalities that they feel like they connect with whatever the quality of the information, they just happen to like this person, and it feels like it's their friend. That kind of thing. Do you find people going straight to the literature?

I definitely know some people like that who they like to go on PubMed by themselves. It's very difficult to interpret something as complex as the medical literature, you find one article. That can be tricky as well even if they're going to the primary data. What are you seeing? Where are people getting their info, and how is that showing up in the doctor-patient interaction?

Neha: I think for over a decade, there's definitely been internet sources, or that's definitely been something that people have come into the clinic with. I saw this on X, Y, and Z. Insert whatever website here. Now, more and more social media, even medical professional colleagues of mine, will say, "Oh, I follow this person, and I'm living by the 30:30:30 rule. I'm like, "What's that? Please share." I think there's a lot of that. I've definitely seen a lot more folks going to AI and just giving it the narrative of what's going on, and then saying, "Well, this is what needs to happen."

All of this information equals this one diagnosis and this one intervention. Yet, I really feel like what they want is for me to negate that, or to reassure them, or to say, "You know what? I can see why it's saying X, Y, and Z, but here's why. As I'm touching you, I'm not seeing this. I'm not feeling this. I'm not hearing this." You can feel a sense of calm when that happens. I think that's what people want, but what they get and where they're going is all of these other sources.

Perry: I certainly see similar. I think since the internet has existed, it's been possible for people to Google things, and patients continue to do that. I don't mind. I like an informed patient, someone who's learned some things. At least we have something to talk about. I have found that in the internet days, in the Google search days, prior to the AI days, there was also the possibility to engage confirmation bias by searching for what you want to be true. The truth is, the internet's very large. If you search for lung cancer cured, no chemo, you will find ample blogs and posts that say, "Oh yes, I didn't have to get chemo, and look, I'm lung cancer free."

The AI era has actually improved that a little bit. The AI models are trained well enough that if you push them in that direction, like, "Can I treat stage three lung cancer without chemotherapy or something like that?" They'll pretty much say no. Here are the current guidelines. Here's a link to the American Cancer Society, so on and so forth. I have actually seen that improve a little bit. People don't get quite as lost in rabbit holes. Then there's the social media. Most of the health questions I get around social media are generally people aren't searching for their own issue. It's, "I happened to see this, and it resonated with me."

You're not going on Instagram searching necessarily for lung cancer treatment. Most people aren't doing that, but you will be scrolling on Instagram and see someone who says, "Did you know that the number one cause of lung cancer in the United States isn't smoking? It's refined sugar or something." This is not true, listeners, by the way, but you'll see something like that, and you'll get questions about that. I agree with Neha.

Fortunately, if you're sitting in front of someone physically there, that does a tremendous amount of work if you can be present and not typing on the screen and looking over your shoulder to try to talk to the patient and if you're not rushing them through a five-minute appointment. The trust with the system is quite low. Most patients report that their trust with their individual doctors is quite a bit higher.

Emily: You mentioned that sometimes people will go to non-medical providers for different treatments and things like that. Sometimes that can be very expensive. It made me think about these other businesses. A lot of people express skepticism about the motives of big corporate hospital systems, the pharmaceutical industry and so on and so forth, but there is also big Wellness with a capital W.

You've got these health spas, you've got big vitamin, and all these supplements and things like that, which is its own profit-generating system. I'm wondering if you see people having similar skepticism toward that business as they have toward traditional medicine, or is there something about the alternative medicine world that just by virtue of being alternative, people give it a pass, or they're willing to trust it more?

Perry: That is mostly what I see is that people are so frustrated with the medical system that it doesn't matter what the alternative is. It's like voting in an election,

It's like, "Am I voting for this guy or am I really voting against that guy?" A lot of people are voting with their feet, sort of against the medical system. Now, there are lots of things the wellness places do a lot better, largely because they don't take insurance. They actually have very high margins, much higher than your typical hospital system in the US, which runs margins of about 3%. These wellness places, 20%, 30% profit margins, and what they'll do is they'll book you right away. They'll get you right in. That's something we're not great at. They'll spend time with you, 30-minute visits, 60-minute visits. The practitioners' part of their training is about listening.

Right now, they're listening like a good car salesman will listen, which is sort of like, "My goal is to sell you a car. I'm going to let you talk, and I'm going to wait until there's something I can hook onto that says, 'You know what would help is this great new car.'" It does mix these things, but the experience for the patient is, "Oh my gosh, I went to this office. It was clean, by the way. It was very nice. It was pretty. The lights were low. I had plenty of time to talk to this person. They seemed very empathetic.

In the end, I spent whatever $100 for the visit. I bought $50 worth of supplements." Is it any wonder that people feel better after that than coming to see me in a crowded clinic, and I walk in 30 minutes late because I've got too many patients to see, and they're out 10 minutes later with a prescription that costs $800 out of pocket before the insurance company pays for it? It's very hard to compete with that, even if what they're selling has no evidence, doesn't actually work, might be toxic, hasn't been vetted, is impure, and all these other problems,

Emily: Or just the human interaction itself-

Perry: Is therapeutic.

Emily: -serves a healing,

Perry: Absolutely.

Neha: I think that if just in Perry's early description of what they provide, in the intro to that, it is what we envisioned we would be providing our patients when we went into medical school. When we went into this field, it was to do exactly what Perry just said, which is to sit with someone, listen to them, let them speak, get curious, know what drives them, what motivates them, what excites them, what is fun for them, and also, as a byproduct, learn what may be going wrong. What are their fears? What are their concerns so that we can address them in an evidence-based way?

I think the other thing that people maybe feel like is lacking is sometimes common-sense ways as well within the healthcare system. Here's what I mean by that. I think that sometimes we talk a lot about the sandwich generation. I think healthcare professionals are in that sandwich in terms of we're the face of this institution that is making everything so difficult for patients. All of the things that you just described, the insurance companies, the big corporate health system, the enterprise-level health system made it so difficult. Now they finally have a face to that, so that's us, and we're toeing the line of trying to explain.

Well, yes, this is why, and trying to explain all that, which I don't think is wrong. That is the reality. Sometimes you do need the prior authorization because we have to start with this medication. I think sometimes you are forced to toe that line to explain what's going on, and then often people want the pill for the ill. When you're standing in the way of that and saying, "Well, here's the evidence, and here's why I don't think you need an antibiotic."

Again, it takes time. You have to have had a relationship with this person so they can swallow that pill and say, "Okay, I'm going to walk away without the prescription, but I know if in a few days I don't feel better, I can have access to this person again, and we can reassess." Because that is not there, this other alternative setting just becomes so attractive, and it is common sense in some way to say, "Hey, you are feeling sick. There's a lot of ways that we can make you feel better by shifting the food that you're eating, by increasing your exercise." It doesn'tstop there because then they also say, and you can take this pill to eliminate the fungus in your blood. I think--

Perry: Toxins. Yes. You got at something that is actually a bit of like a trust hack that I see particularly online and also in some of these wellness spaces, which is that humans have a cognitive bias that we're more likely to trust someone who seems certain, which is why if you do look on Instagram and look at wellness influencers and stuff, what you find is a great deal of rather extreme statements. These are the three foods in your pantry that will kill you. I actually saw one the other day that was-- farmed salmon is the most toxic food on earth. Just on the surface, there's a bunch of mushrooms that if you eat, you die within six hours, so it can't be the most toxic.

Not to mention pufferfish and sodium, but t. That hack works, and doctors, by training, won't do that. Nor should we, by the way, even when there's a clear-cut indication, and someone comes that they have community-acquired pneumonia, and we say, "We're going to put you on an antibiotic." That's what the evidence says. They say, "Am I going to feel better?" We say, "It won't eliminate the symptoms immediately, but it certainly will shorten the duration of symptoms and reduce infectivity."

We've been trained so much to couch the risk and benefit of everything that we do that it actually-- it's very hard to compete with people who say, "By the way, if you get this vaccine, you'll die within the next 12 months." Someone asks us that, and we say, "No, no, no. There's no, there's no evidence of that." Of course, nothing is risk-free. Of course, someone could have an anaphylactic reaction.

We always come back to that balance and nuance, and it's really hard to convey that and also build trust again if you don't have adequate time to do it, because otherwise, people who are scared are going to just flock to certainty. See, this guy seems to know what he's talking about. He seems pretty certain that you don't need chemotherapy for cancer. I like this guy, whereas we say, "Well, the studies show that on average, chemotherapy improves life expectancy." That kind of stuff. It's a real it's a real problem.

Neha: Sorry, just to add to that piece. I think the converse sometimes is also true where we convey a lot of certainty in our expertise and our expert opinion, and then there's a big practice-changing study that comes out, and we have not built in the humility to how we talk to people and how we should-- I think we're very well trained at, "Oh yes. I can't say with complete certainty," but sometimes we also come at people, particularly at an institutional expert level, with this, "If you don't do this, you are not following the science, and you are wrong."

I think that's very hard to convey the message of, "Here's the best knowledge that we have so far, and we are going to continue to ensure that we're providing you with the best knowledge based on these additional studies. Sometimes things might change, and that's only because we are trying to give you the newer recommendation based on the newest, best available science." I think we sometimes fall down on that side as well.

Perry: On the public communication side, absolutely. I think one-on-one with a doctor, you tend to get the nuance. It's people like us, Neha, who are talking to a broad population of people, we're trying to keep it simple. We've got messaging that we want people to understand. Like the MMR vaccine does not cause autism. We have these things that-- There's, I think, a tendency, and I think this is actually where some of the public health messaging in COVID went wrong, that because you see that the messaging on the other side, these vaccines will kill you within 30 days.

Which you'll recall, there was that when the vaccines were first getting rolled out, like it's going to be a mass extinction event. You have people saying it's going to be a mass extinction event, this vaccine rollout. I think it was very hard for public health officials in that setting to not lean heavily in the other direction, just so that there's a net balance. I think that was probably a mistake, and in the end, I think conveying a little more of the actual uncertainty around things would have worked better. It's really hard to do when you have someone standing next to you screaming the extreme statement.

Neha: Absolutely.

Emily: I was going to ask about this concept of medical reversals. At The Nocturnists, we spoke to a physician, Dr. Adam Sifu, who I think wrote a book that's just called Medical Reversal. We were talking to a pediatrician earlier today about how, with infants sleeping, first it was on their tummy, and then it was on their side, and then it was on their back, and the guidelines kept changing, or peanut exposure, it was like, "Don't give them peanuts," and then it was like, "Just kidding. Give them peanuts as soon as you can." With COVID, obviously, there was a number of medical reversals that happened in a very short, compressed period of time.

In the menopause community, there's a lot of conversations about the medical reversals related to hormone replacement therapy, "It's going to give you a heart attack. Just kidding." Do we need to do a better job communicating to the public that science is alive and it's evolving? What do we say to people who see these pendulum swings and then they're just like, "I'm out," you guys don't know what you're talking about. I'm going to drink my [crosstalk] raw milk.

Yes, exactly. With nutrition, and some of it is agenda-driven and profit-driven. We've learned a lot about big sugar and how in the '90s everything was about being low-fat, but it was packed with sugar, and now we're realizing that the sugar is harmful. It's like, "Well, where did that narrative come from?" You start to get into some of these more systemic issues. How do you think about that, and how do you talk to patients about that?

Neha: I think that this is very difficult in the primary care setting as well. Certainly at the health communication level, when you're talking at the population level, but even in the clinic, and I think that what I usually err on is sort of like the 80:20 rule. There is 80% of what we know, which is very much there is a consensus around. This is particularly around conversations around food and nutrition. It's not a surprise what a healthy plate looks like. Now, we can play around at the margins, and it's constantly evolving whether or not 1 egg, 10 eggs, what is going to cause disease or worsen your health.

We can play around with this, but 80% of what is going to keep you healthy-- we know for a fact that it's going to be fruits, vegetables, whole grains. This is where I think the common-sense piece, where we have to meet people where they believe that food and nutrition plays a major role in their health. They want us to talk about that. I think that we have to address that. They believe that environmental pollution impacts their health. We have to acknowledge that in what we're saying.

Now we can say that, but there is an evolving literature around some of the edges, so some of the specifics may change. As soon as we have that evidence, we're going to talk to you about how these things might change. That's how I do it in my clinic, one-on-one.

Perry: I think that's incredibly well said. It's worth highlighting that most of medicine is pretty consistent over time, but you don't hear about that in the news because that's not interesting. It's not interesting to say anymore that smoking causes lung cancer. What would be interesting is if a study came out that said smoking doesn't cause lung cancer, and that'll get 8 million headlines and a bunch of patients calling us, being like, "What were you talking about?" Nevertheless, these things do happen, and I try to convey to patients. Really, when I'm teaching the med students and residents critical appraisal of the literature, is that in medicine, evidence has a weight.

There's a weight of evidence, and it accumulates over time on one side of the scale, and it's the best we have. In some cases, we have little weight on either side, and it's leaning this way. Who really knows? In some cases, we have a lot of weight, but things could still change in the future. When I'm talking to patients, I try to describe, "This is a feature, not a bug. "What makes science different from religion is that there's nothing set in stone. We continue to learn, and you want people to do this. We learn how to do studies better. We learn how to enroll a more representative population.

Even things that are biologically true may behave differently over time as the makeup of the population changes, as the comorbidities change. We should expect it to evolve, and we should support the research that adds weight to one side of the scale or another. When your doctor says, "Oh, by the way, remember I told you never eat an egg again because eggs raise cholesterol." Well, more recent data suggests it's not that big a deal, and there's a lot of good stuff in eggs, so go ahead. The response should be, "Oh, great. I'm glad someone studied that and didn't just take it for granted because it was written in a book somewhere." That's what makes medicine--

Neha: I think this is where there's also value sometimes to social media. Hear me out, and what I mean by this is when you're seeing a signal in patient complaints around something. I'm thinking specifically around IUD insertion, and you had a lot of women saying that that was the worst process of my life. I had so much pain, and the counseling at the time of insertion was, "Oh, it's fine. You should be fine. Here's a pain reliever, if you need it." I think what we have to do-- again, this comes back to humility and recognizing that yes, science is constantly evolving, and we need patient voices also to help us understand the direction of what we're studying. Yes, go ahead, sorry.

Perry: This is so critical. So many of the enduring health-related conspiracy theories. If you trace the history back, you find exactly this: a real story of patients not being listened to. We recently, on our podcast, were talking about ticks. It's tick season in Connecticut. There's lots of fun tick diseases to talk about, but we dug into the history of Lyme disease, and as you probably know, there is a lot of information and disinformation and misinformation about Lyme disease out there. A lot of controversy. Obviously RFK Jr. has opinions. He mentioned it was a bioweapon.

There's all sorts of stuff, but if you go back in time to when Lyme disease was discovered, late '60s, early '70s, what you had was a group of moms in Lyme, Connecticut, whose kids had all been diagnosed with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, and they went to their doctors and were like, "All our kids can't have JRA. This is a rare condition. Why do they all have it? They're all the same age," whatever. The doctor said, "No, no, no. It's juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. Look at the swollen knee," whatever. Until eventually, someone took these moms seriously and said, "Maybe there's something else." This was actually done at Yale.

Borrelia burgdorferi, that spirochete that causes Lyme disease, was discovered and could be treated and so on and so forth. I believe that those origin stories of things, the COVID vaccine isn't too different. Percolate down through history, even among people who don't know that story, it somehow persists, and we still have to deal with that stuff. To the extent that we can actually listen to patients about what they're telling us, doctors 20 years from now will thank us because this whole ecosystem of alternate science won't have a chance to develop if we actually do the right science at the beginning. That's all.

[music]

Emily: I love what you said, Neha, about looking for signals in the population, because oftentimes when it's a one-on-one interaction between a clinician and a patient, it's relatively easy in a just human interaction to get underneath the fear, figure out what is this really about. Is it really about a blood transfusion, or is it really about this other thing that happened to you four years ago, and that's driving this? Usually, with a conversation or a couple conversations, you can get at what's really going on, but it's like, how do you do that at a population level? With Lyme, it's like, "Well, what's really going on?"

Actually, the root of this comes from a mass distrust event. I'm wondering if that's a fertile ground for new research. Especially with social media and AI and just big data. Wouldn't it be interesting if we could put sensors or antennas around, like in Twitter or whatever, in TikTok, and just get like a weather report. Like every week or every month or every year. What are people talking about? What's bothering them? What are their fears? Where is their mistrust located? Almost like population-level couples therapy. It's like, "Was your fight really about the burrito in the fridge, or was it about something else?" Can we do that at a mass scale? Does that does that even make sense?

Neha: I love that. You hit on something that I think is so important in the clinic, which is that you get to pilot test your messaging and recalibrate in real time as you're talking to someone because you get their facial movement, or they're leaning in or they're leaning out. You can say, "This tack that I'm taking is not working. I've got to adjust. I've got to figure out what is going to actually connect with this patient." You have the space and the ability to do that when you're one-on-one with someone, or in a group visit. I think that's a very interesting idea.

I do feel like that's where a lot of evidence is coming from, where you percolate these messages or percolating, and then it's on us. I think it's really interesting, Perry, what you said that you've noticed this in social media. These messages around the wellness industry, so you created a podcast to try to address some of the main questions that you are hearing. Is that how you came up with this concept of your podcast?

Perry: Yes, absolutely. It was just sort of the idea. You can say in a minute and 30 seconds of a clip on Instagram, you can generate about 45 minutes' worth of things to debunk, basically. Not everything out there is fake either. There's some people giving great advice, and actually, there's some great science communicators on Instagram. Particularly when it comes to diet and stuff like that, I love a good Instagram recipe. It's like it's quick. You see people making the pan these healthy things. They're high protein, whatever. What was missing? I felt like, and it's not for everyone. It's for people who actually want to listen for an hour.

What was missing was what's the data behind this claim? What we find-- there's some big themes that keep emerging. We pick one topic a week, but there's some big themes that emerge. One is that there's a dramatic overreliance on biological plausibility. Wellness influencers will say, "Did you know that one of the proteins in the electron transport chain changes conformation in response to 580-nanometer red light? Therefore, if you put red light on your skin, it will reduce your wrinkles." There's this leap from this actually true fact to this clinical outcome. As a researcher, I know that I'm not allowed to do that.

I have to have a hypothesis that has some basis in fact, and then I have to design an experiment to test whether it leads the outcome. We wanted to bring to light that process and say, "Here's what's true. Sure, if you isolate this protein in a petri dish and you shoot a laser at it, this is what actually happens. Now here's what happens when you try it in mice. Here's what happens when you try it in humans. Here's what it costs. Here's who's making money off of this and not." For some things, we'll come down and be like, yes, this seems good. We did a whole creatine episode and dug through all the randomized trial data.

In the end, at least for people trying to build some muscle, seems pretty good. There's some decent data here. The weight of evidence leans in this direction, and then for some stuff, obviously, it's on the other side. We felt like there needed to be someone doing fact-checking and explaining the science underneath it all, because actually the science is I think is the coolest part. Teaching people how to think scientifically again, as opposed to with their gut, is maybe the er goal of the whole podcast.

Neha: I think, Emily, what you said also is really interesting in terms of directing research questions as well. This again, I'll be very anecdotal. I remember in med school, so as I mentioned, growing up, the things that my parents did were yoga, deep breathing exercises. This is what the foundation and everyone in my community was doing that. We had a lecture on heart disease, and this is about 20 years ago or so.

I went to the professor, and I was like, "Yes, what do you think about yoga as an intervention?" That is just woo woo, new age banana stuff, and then it took us being able to have fMRI studies and to take this 1,000s of year old tradition and be able to say, "Yes, the science show. Yes science. Yes, it does have benefits." I think we also need to have some humility in terms of what kinds of questions we're asking.

Where are we sort of-- Is this culturally competent in terms of what we'll give funding to, or where we'll spend our time investigating? I think that those are also pieces that we need to be thinking about as clinicians, because these are the things that people are asking in the clinic. Should I do-- but you're doing [unintelligible 00:49:06]? Now we have more evidence, but we didn't always answer that question in a way that was culturally competent, I think, or responsive to what people were seeing in their communities.

Emily: Yes, I think learning how to attune to the public, or I guess a cruder way of saying it, is like read the room. I'm just thinking about the vaccine autism scenario. I interviewed a pediatrician who was talking about moms and just how they were more afraid of autism than they were of measles for whatever reason. Maybe it's because the vaccine has been so effective there just isn't a lot of measles around. If you haven't seen it, you're not afraid of it. Maybe it's because when they were growing up, measles was normal, and people had measles parties and to inoculate each other.

To them, that was part of their culture, and it just didn't scare them that much. Even though there is a subset of kids who get very, very ill and who can die from that, it was rare enough. If you scale it to a population level, that's a lot of dead kids. If you're just in your family or in your community, maybe you don't see that. The fear isn't as visceral, whereas we do have rising rates of autism, and people see that everywhere, and they're terrified. Why isn't there more research on autism? I think when RFK started to talk about autism and say "Oh, we're going to pour all this money into it." Whatever his motives, whatever his misinformation, people felt seen.

Perry: Good.

Emily: I'm wondering, yeah, like what you think about how the health research and medical industry can attune better to the public and read the room and figure out what's actually concerning people, and how are people talking about that right now?

Perry: There's a lot of ways that research can be done better, and that's a major one. I think it is the NIH and the government sources of funding that will really have to be the place that these questions get answered. Pharmaceutical companies might have deep pockets, but they're really designed to identify and treat diseases, not particularly to prevent disease. Although, we have preventative drugs, we have statins, we have vaccines, and things, but they're all still tied to a disease-based outcome like MI. The public and the wellness industry leans into this is interested in maintaining health. They're interested in health span.

How long can I live and be functional and happy and do the things I want to do? Everyone wants that to be as long as possible. there's no pharmaceutical company that can even design a trial with a drug to test that because it wouldn't be long enough, and who knows how you'd even start biologically. It is the place for government funders to listen to the people. We're their employers, so they say. To listen to the people. What are we worried about? Preserving cognition. Yes, we're worried about childhood development.

We're not just in autism, which we of course are, but we're worried about childhood development in the age of phones and social media and rapid videos and all these kind of things. There's not many sources of funding to study that stuff. The NIH, for a long time, and the medical research community have been disease-focused. Name your disease. The NIH is full of centers that are based on diseases. My I apply for grants from the National Institutes of Diabetes, Digestive, and Kidney Disease.

It's all oriented that way, and that's fine. By the way, we've done such an amazing job at reducing the burden of disease over the past 100 years in medical research, but maintaining health is a bigger challenge, and one that's probably not going to be driven by some cool new pharmaceutical product. I don't know, maybe GLP ones. No, it's going to be based on lifestyle changes. I think people are desperate for those studies to be done at high quality, and I am encouraged to see people like RFK at least nodding in that direction. Although, yes, I know that some of his pre-held beliefs might color the direction that funding goes.

Neha: I think this again gets to trust, which is that you. I completely agree with you. I think the vast majority, if we're talking 80:20 again, that people want to be healthy. They want their healthcare system to lean into health and not into waiting, waiting, waiting until you're sick. Blood pressure, heart rate, a lot of the vitals that we check are lagging indicators of once that has shifted, you're in some disease state potentially once you're diagnosed with hypertension, but people want to be able to catch this, or that they're on some trajectory to that beforehand, so that they can make the lifestyle change.

We can see that there is a need, and there is a motivation for people. They do want to change in some way. I don't know that necessarily it's that people don't want to change their habits. It's just that they want to be told, "If I do this one thing," then everything will change. I think that's where we do need high-quality studies to show how do all of these lifestyle pieces work together with nutrition, with sleep. How does that work in tandem with physical activity so that we can keep you and your child-- I think children, having children, is a major motivating factor for people, and I think that's why they're look-- You have the MAHA movement that's really looking at environmental exposures.

Now, we might not necessarily agree with the agenda or what they're necessarily thinking is the underlying cause, so it's not vaccines, but something is happening in terms of earlier diagnoses of colon cancers and other. We have to acknowledge, and we have to say-- I think your point is so well taken, Perry, is that this is a question that we, our government, is going to answer, and here's how much money we're investing, and it's going to be health-focused, not necessarily disease-focused. I think we have to say that very clearly.

Emily: I was thinking about some of the people we interviewed on the street when we were doing research on this, and we interviewed all sorts of people, just all socioeconomic status, and one pattern that came up a little bit, especially from the people who were really low socioeconomic status, out of care, that we heard a couple of times is like parasites. That was a word that kept coming up. I remember there was this one woman; she was like smoking a cigarette outside of the Walmart, and she said, "Well, our bodies are infested with parasites, and the doctors don't even want to touch that. They don't even want to look at that.

They pretend that doesn't exist. What about all these parasites?" I think it can be easy to just blow that off and say that person clearly has no idea what they're talking about, and that's a conspiracy theory or whatever. You look at the news, and it's like headlines about plastics. Plastics have been found in the testicles of men. Plastics have been found in the placenta of pregnant women, and why aren't we talking about that? Some of this stuff around food dyes and like this stuff that's just in the environment, why aren't we talking about that? It just made me think about the parasites thing.

Obviously those aren't the same, but there is a little bit of an underlying theme, which is instead of medicine reacting once I've already developed a disease, what about the water we swim in, and what about some of these environmental exposures and lifestyle things? Neha, you have special training in lifestyle medicine, so I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on that. When I was in med school, we didn't really learn about nutrition at all. Do you think that medicine needs to evolve to start to encompass some of these topics and take them more seriously?

Neha: Yes, I absolutely do. I think that movement is already happening. We have residency programs that are focusing on lifestyle medicine, we have fellowships that are focusing on lifestyle medicine across the country. I think we really have to be thinking about it in the same way we think about any other intervention. What is the dose? What is that intensive therapeutic lifestyle intervention that is actually going to make a difference in terms of prevention, in terms of management? If we look at the guidelines of a vast majority of chronic diseases, whether it's hypertension or diabetes or even chronic kidney disease, lifestyle intervention is that throwaway line at the bottom.

I think oftentimes, we think that our patients are just not going to be interested in that. That they want really the medication, or they're going to wait until there's something where they feel sick before they make the change. I know I see it in my clinic and the people that I talk to, they, I think, though, are thinking about it as a medication. They're like, "What is the dose of fiber that I need? How much fiber exactly? How many blueberries do I need to eat so that I don't get dementia?" I think we have to have a curriculum that helps us understand again that this is a dietary pattern. What is the pattern? How do we prescribe that pattern? I keep seeing media reports of, "Exercise in a pill. If you take this pill, it's the same amount. You'll have all--

Neha: If only.

Emily: It's like how do we actually prescribe the exercise, and how do we have this curriculum on behavior change? In medicine, I think we often don't do things unless we do a test, and then we can change our management based on the test, and so we don't necessarily ask about some of these things because we don't necessarily know how to change our management.

We don't have teams of nutritionists, and mental health professionals, or behavioral health professionals that will help us do this because it's not all on the physician to do all of this. This is very much a team-based sport. I think we haven't necessarily leaned into it because we don't have the supporting cast necessarily that's also trained to do this in the way that is going to be the right therapeutic intervention to show a difference to maintain health.

When it comes to the microplastics, I think that is so interesting. My husband's a gastroenterologist, and he says the number of people that come in with outside testing that that says, "Here's my fungal count and here's my parasite level. Do something about this." He's just like, "Why did you pay for this test?" I think we have to figure out a way of talking about environmental exposures because we don't yet have the evidence, I think, to Perry's point for some of these things. In my clinic, I think about it in the framing of the precautionary principle. Just because I don't know, I think that there is enough evidence of microplastics and cardiovascular disease.

I think we need to acknowledge and say we don't know all of the answers yet. This gets to Perry's point about this is evolving. This science is evolving. I understand. I agree, this is a concern. Here are ways that you can minimize plastic exposure, and we're still learning the extent to which this is going to impact your health, but this is the common sense part of it. People are worried. Again, this gets to what Perry said earlier. Biologic plausibility. We don't want to go all in as physicians and say, Yes, microplastics are causing everything." I think we do have to meet people where they are and where they want to make the change.

Perry: I'm thinking through the implications.

Emily: Yes, please. I'm very curious.

Perry: Lifestyle modification is difficult for many reasons. All humans are creatures of habit. We did a randomized trial here once in patients with heart failure about a bunch of different digital health devices to improve their well-being. The one that worked the best for our outcome, which was like a heart failure quality of life score, was the one they liked using the least. [laughs] It was because it was the one that forced them to do stuff. Annoyed them to get up and walk, and annoyed them to take their medication. It wasn't pleasant, and it just drilled home to me, like, "Huh. Sometimes the most effective things are the things that don't come naturally to us," right?

We have to actually make changes. I think we also have to recognize, and this is part of building trust in a culturally sensitive way, how difficult lifestyle changes can be for some people in this country just based on the circumstances of their life. It's great to say, "Oh, fresh meats and produce," but if you don't have a car, and the closest supermarket is five miles away, that's just not going to happen.

I think one of the concerns I have actually about the MAHA movement and wellness in general is that it's hyper-individualistic. In its worst incarnation, it says everything that's wrong with you is your own fault, right? Like you ate the wrong food, you didn't drink the right milk. You did all this stuff, and that's why you're having this problem, but don't worry, because if you change it all, this problem will go away.

I think it is important for us all to remember how much of health outcomes on a population level are driven by policy and not individual choice. Maybe this is me being cynical, but I do worry that some of the hyper-individualistic, "It's all on you to get yourself better, or to get yourself sick," will lead to further decreases in trust of public health interventions. I think they're somehow tied together almost. That it's like, we don't need Big Brother government coming down and telling us what to do.

Fixing the water supply, or providing free vaccinations, or things like that, because as long as you eat these appropriate supplements, you're going to be fine. I'm not saying this is 100% how it works, but it is something I just want to have out there that we have a duty when we're communicating to the public, to also remember to communicate to people who are in charge of policy, and that those decisions can have really wide-ranging impacts.

Neha: I think that's one area where I am somewhat optimistic in that we have a very robust insurance system that covers insulin or diabetes medication, but not necessarily one that will give you a produce prescription.

Perry: Chicken breast. [chuckles]

Neha: Or one that will give you access to a gym. That's just not something that we prescribe. It'll be a fun thing to write on your prescription pad and be like, "Ah, exercise three-- here you go." The actual funding of that, we don't necessarily do. I think that is a key point in terms of if you're going to consider this a prescription, it has to be accessible at a population level. Yes, I fully agree with that.

Emily: Well, we've covered a lot of ground so far. I feel like we could keep going for another hour, but I know our time is limited, so as we bring this to a close, Neha and Perry, wondering if there's any final thoughts, final words about trust in medicine, things that the medical community could do better, or suggestions for how to get good information, or just any final thoughts to close us out.

Perry: I'll just say that if you want to know the number one surefire way to lose that stubborn belly fat, you can subscribe to my [inaudible 01:05:59]

[laughter]

Emily: For the low, low price.

Perry: I was testing everyone to see if they were paying attention. No, I think I'm so glad that we had the opportunity to talk about this. The one take-home for me here is trust takes time. Trust takes communication. We had some time here. We got to communicate. I hope people can hear some of the things that we're saying and bring them back to their own practices. If you're a healthcare professional, or their own relationships, if you're not, so thanks for having me on.

Neha: I thank you for the opportunity to have this conversation. I fully agree with Perry. I think the only additional piece I think that we didn't necessarily talk about is recognizing that these physicians that want so badly, or health professionals that want so badly, to have these trusting relationships with their patients, are also operating in systems where efficiency means something very different to the people that are in charge of the systems.

I don't want to necessarily end on a negative note, but I think that we do need to think about systems where physicians are seen somewhat as widgets, or cogs in a wheel that have to move people through in this efficient manner to address metrics like access and other things when we really need to shift what metric is it that's most important to us. I think if we're really in an age where people are losing trust in healthcare professionals and institutions, then maybe we need to think about changing those underlying metrics.

Really get back to what worked optimally before, which was having time with someone that you had a relationship with, so that when there are changes in the science, or the literature, you can go back to this person and trust that what they are recommending for you is based on their interest in your health, and that they're doing this with compassion and the best knowledge available at that time.

Emily: I think that's a good note to end on. I think that's a positive note, something to strive for and to aim for. I have been speaking with Dr. Neha Pathik and Dr. Perry Wilson. This has been really fun. I've really enjoyed speaking with both of you. I hope the audience will check out both of you and your writing, and your work, and your podcast, Perry, with Emily Oster. That sounds like a great resource. Thank you so much for doing this and for having this conversation.

Neha: Thank you so much.

Perry: Sure. Thanks.


0:00/1:34